Strict liability for abuse committed by non-employees: the AA case

The High Court of Australia handed down a significant decision last week in  AA v The Trustees of the Roman Catholic Church for the Diocese of Maitland-Newcastle [2026] HCA 2 (11 Feb 2026). The decision expands the strict liability of churches and other organisations undertaking the care of children, by finding that an institution owes a “non-delegable duty” to such children, to ensure that no-one entrusted to care for them commits abuse. In reaching this decision, the court had to over-rule a previous decision in the Lepore case.

As Edelman J commented:

[341] The overruling of Lepore will have a significant effect upon the common law in this country, including upon proceedings concerning historic sexual abuse, such as this case. Any legal entity—including any unincorporated organisation like the Diocese that is required to be treated as a legal entity—which assumes responsibility to ensure that reasonable care is taken of another’s person or property (goods or land) will be liable if a third party intentionally causes injury to that other person or their property within the scope of the responsibility assumed.

I am presenting a paper at an academic conference outlining the decision, which is available for download here.

New federal hate speech laws- impact on religious freedom?

After the dreadful terrorist incident at Bondi on December 14 2025, where 15 folk from the Jewish community were murdered, the Federal government has introduced new “hate speech” laws at the national level. Whenever there is a proposal to target “hate speech” there is always a potential danger that unpopular religious views will be caught up in the ban. However, it seems that the recently enacted changes will have little impact on religious freedom in Australia, except where religion is offered as a reason to justify calls for violence against others. In this post I will try to spell out what the changes are, and why they seem to be a reasonable response to the danger of terrorist violence.

Continue reading